Quick Thought on Karl

Karl was the kid in the other cage, opposite Sawyer, before Kate was put in there.

Could Karl have been one of the Tailies that was kidnapped early in Season 2? There were something like 7 or 9 people kidnapped on the 2nd attack (first being when Eko was dragged into the jungle and killed the two Others.

Also...there were no original Tailies around to identify him as one of the Tailies.

Just something to think about.